“ Awesome drinks and meal! Wonderful experience, great atmosphere ... a winner! You can't go wrong here! ”

“ Great drinks! Reasonable pricing. Swordfish and salmon entrees very good! Blueberry white chocolate bread pudding fantastic... home made to boot!! Wait staff attentive. Ambiance very nice. ”

“ Really good food! Too 3 best grilled shrimps I've ever had! Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious! Will go back here next time I'm in Cape Cod. ”

“ We ate here when visiting Chatham this weekend. It was the best surprise of the entire trip, the food was excellent, service was extremely accommodating and the drinks perfect. I ordered the roasted lobster and can honestly say it was the best I ever had. My partner had the broiled scallops and thought they were cooked to perfection. Highly recommend Mahoney's if you're in the area. ”

“ Mahoney's is always a great experience. The food is consistently good, they easily accommodate gluten-free diners, the bartenders are cheery and the dining room is clean and elegant. We've been coming for years and are never disappointed! ”

“ This place is fabulous. Service was a 10. Food was delicious. Lobster bisque, blackened shrimp, salad, seafood Atlantic steaming bowl, and even the bread, were all excellent. Restaurant was clean and bar area is very nice. This place gets busy, so get there early. ”

“ This is gonna be a weird review! My family was visiting Cape Cod and we had heard great things about the food here so decided to go for dinner. We were pleasantly surprised there was only a 20 minute wait for a table. The problem was once we were seated, it was nearly 20 minutes (about 15) before our waitress came to greet us. The table next to us informed us they were short staffed and that things had been very slow all night - they had been there for 3 hours when we arrived. I get it, that happens. When the waitress came over and we said hello, we asked how she was doing and she responded, verbatim, "mediocre at best." She was in a super upset mood, which made it really awkward. The rave reviews we had heard of this place were true in that the food was excellent. No complaints! Unfortunately we never received the clam chowder we ordered, as they had run out. So here's where it gets weird. We were totally ready to put the sub-par service out of our minds and leave on a good note, when the waitress came over to our table..crying. She told us she was having a terrible night and was embarrassed and wanted to give us a dessert to apologize for the poor service, even though we hadn't complained. We awkwardly tried to console her (we also had our 5 year old son with us which made it more awkward, as he couldn't understand why our waitress was so upset). We appreciated the gesture of the complimentary dessert. She then brought the bill and, although the dessert wasn't on it as she had promised, the clam chowder was still on the bill even though they were out. We didn't have another half hour to wait around to deal with this, as she had already run our credit card when we saw the chowder on the itemized receipt. So we let it be as it was, and chalked it all up to the weirdest dining experience ever....great food, crying waitress and all. ”

“ Walking in, it has such a welcoming and homey vibe. The bar was full and the dim lighting was a great setting for dinner. Even though it was 8:30 ( and they close at 9:00) they sat us. Our waitress was very sweet and very attentive. Every time the water glass was empty she was right there to fill it up, check in on the meal and etc. I had the prickly pear margarita and it was delicious- not to mention it was generous in its libations! For dinner my partner had the salmon, and absolutely loved it. He said the mash was a perfect pairing with it. I had the stuffed chicken and the flavors were incredible. It was a generous portion, and the mash was also a great pairing with the meal ( not to mention the sauce was a perfect addition) The prices are a little higher than "typical", but expected for a good meal. We will come back! ”